Discussion about this post

User's avatar
JRC21's avatar

I have access to the Athletic, courtesy of a New York Times subscription. I realize that reading the comments section to any article of any kind on public media is not the greatest use of time, but I made the mistake of reading the comments to the Paul Skenes wins NL RoY article. The wailing of Padres fans on behalf of Jackson Merrill was beyond belief. All the usual arguments: he played every day; the Padres made the playoffs thanks to him; the vote reflected east coast bias (!?!); the Pirates record was the same with Skenes as without him in 2023 so he wasn’t valuable. The biggest collection of whining I’ve read in a long time.

There was some pushback, mainly around all the objective metrics favoring Skenes as well as the historic nature of his season. And as someone pointed out, if Cherington called up Preller and offered Skenes for Merrill straight up, how long would it take to Preller to accept? A nano second.

Expand full comment
Catch22's avatar

Well deserved, Mr. Skenes.

Nice seeing him and the Livvy at the Steelers/Ravens game. They really seem to enjoy the 'Burgh.

Skenes is going to lead the way when the Bucco's bust into October in 2025.

Expand full comment
18 more comments...

No posts