Discussion about this post

User's avatar
NMR's avatar

The collapse of the 2015 club has been routinely blamed on huge drops in production from their best players.

Their Top 5 most valuable players in 2016 were worth 10 less WAR than their Top 5 most valuable players in 2015 en route to a 20-game drop in the win column.

Is there a fan alive who realizes the 2023 club's Top 5 most valuable players *also* cratered to a 10 WAR drop in value last season? They did! Hayes, Suwinski, Reynolds, Keller, and Bednar were worth 10 less WAR last year and the club still won as many games as the year before.

For those who seem to get off wallowing in their own misery, that is a *good* outcome! To lose that much production from your core and still win as many games points to *positive* projection in the future.

Scratch back even half that value and this is a .500 ballclub without a single outside addition.

We scoff when they say their best shot at improvement is internal, but next year that turns out to be absolutely true. All the more reason to be bold and buy into this club instead of waiting to add. The Division is wide open.

Expand full comment
NMR's avatar

You can argue Judge earned it but unanimously, with Bobby Witt putting up the highest percentage of team WAR in baseball for a low-budget team who made the playoff, is absolutely hilarious east coast bias.

Expand full comment
45 more comments...

No posts