52 Comments

The Pirates reinstated Endy, Oviedo, Moreta and Stratton from the 60-day IL. Heller, Jefferies and Mattson were outrighted to AAA. They'll probably all opt for free agency.

Expand full comment

Fangraphs has their Top 50 FAs article up: https://blogs.fangraphs.com/2025-top-50-mlb-free-agents/

There aren't a lot of interesting position players in our price range, and if we sign anyone from this group it would likely be a reliever (which we need!). Best realistic option from the position players? I'll go with O'Neil.

Expand full comment

MLBTR now has their top 50 up, and surprisingly two of their four writers predict O'Neil to sign with us: https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2024/11/2024-25-top-50-mlb-free-agents-with-predictions.html

Expand full comment

What's better than one Oneil?

Expand full comment

One of the two who didn't predict us with O'Neil predicts Conforto to end up with us, and I'd like that too.

Expand full comment

I’m guessing they will try and sneak both Grey and Cabbage through waivers again at some point this offseason. Cabbage has massive strikeout issues but had a 30/30 season in the PCL in 23! Not a bad guy to have at AAA and a healthy choice to move from Beer to Cabbage😜

Expand full comment

Cabbage . . . . . Imagine the Cherington word salad potential . . . .

Expand full comment

He can make coleslaw out of cabbage.

Expand full comment

Wordslaw

Expand full comment

Apparently the pirates claimed Trey Cabbage

Expand full comment

Mel, i think you should do a bit this winter where you make posts like this but some are legit made up names and then we keep score on who actually figures it out.

Barney Bologna claimed off waivers.

Expand full comment

I'll slip a couple in, already have a pretty good one in mind.

Expand full comment

this award puts an exclamation point on the IKF 2025 $7.5 salary blunder

Expand full comment
Nov 4Liked by NolaJeffy(BnP)

Buccos off-season...

-Trade for Wilyer Abreu (Boston is looking for pitching)

-Sign Kim to play SS

-Sign Rizzo on the cheap looking for a bounce back

-Sign a couple legit BP arms - entertain the idea of bringing Chapman back

If not now, when?

Expand full comment

You know that if the Bucs did sign Rizzo, he would get hit in the hands again and mis at least half the season as his bones can’t take any more hits and he won’t move back any…..

Expand full comment

I could live with this, even Rizzo, unlike some of the others. Inclined to agree that Kim is probably too pricy, but maybe you try and jump the market and throw some $$$ at a guy before the market settles post-Soto?

Expand full comment

Added Rizzo due to Pirates budget.

Expand full comment

All considered they could do far worse.

Expand full comment

Sounds nice, but I’m prepared to Triolo winning the GG be the highlight of the offseason……😕

Expand full comment
author
Nov 4·edited Nov 4Author

Pass on Rizzo, but overall, that'd be a step in the right direction.

Expand full comment

Love Kim, but a contender will probably throw a contract outside the Bucs price range at him.

Rizzo seems washed to me. The guy's power has disappeared.

Expand full comment
author

I like the idea of targeting Kim, but yeah, I'd be hard pressed to think they're able to secure his services.

That's why my hypotheticals would include telling the Diamondbacks you'll take Montgomery off their hands if Lawlar is included, calling the Dodgers about Freeland since they're expected to highly target Adames, or looking to the Guardians or Athletics.

Expand full comment
author

Speaking of bounce backs though, I'd be game bringing in Yoan Moncada, whose biggest issue has been remaining healthy.

Expand full comment
Nov 4Liked by NolaJeffy(BnP)

man i feel old.

Expand full comment
author

That White Sox future super stardom filled roster really fizzled out lol

Expand full comment
Nov 4Liked by NolaJeffy(BnP)

So, IOW, try to make the team better? Damn, what a novel idea!

Expand full comment
author

FWIW, an infield of Key (3B), IKF (SS), Nicky G (2B), and Tree (1B) would at least be one hell of a defensively competent infield.

No, this is not a comment saying that that should in fact happen.

Expand full comment
Nov 4Liked by NolaJeffy(BnP)

Better yet, bring Santana (GG at 1B in the AL) back or sign Christian Walker (GG at 1B in the NL) and let Triolo back up all four positions because it's inevitable that someone will go down with an extended injury.

Or trade for Montcastle, a GG finalist and much younger than the other two.

Expand full comment

Walker is the only 1b in free agency that interests me. Maybe he won't break the bank due to his age.

Expand full comment
author

Any of which I think should be considered. Though personally, I'd prefer to go the route of finding outfielders, and moving Reynolds to 1B.

Expand full comment
Nov 4Liked by NolaJeffy(BnP)

Bingo!

Honestly surprises me we seem desperate to find that unicorn low dollar big bopper 1B when Bryan Reynolds is staring us in the face.

Expand full comment
author

Agreed. Granted, the move to 1B isn't as easy as we'd like to believe, but he's also bad in OF. At least have the closest thing to a 1B profiled bat we've had since Bell. Is rather roll the dice on an OF who will hopefully at least be a defensive upgrade to help out our pitching staff.

Expand full comment
Nov 4Liked by NolaJeffy(BnP)

1b would be ideal, but RF would be ok as well. Too much grass for him playing LF in PNC. Abreu would eat all the grass up and Reynolds would do fine in RF.

Expand full comment
author

There are a lot of potential options for them to actually upgrade the team. Lets hope they take initiative to do so, one way or another.

Expand full comment
Nov 4Liked by NolaJeffy(BnP)

How can you suggest this? Have you lost your mind? 🧌

Expand full comment
author

Yes, yes I have

Expand full comment

Just a look at the Pirates finish for 2024. Lots of BS about how we succeeded in finishing with the same record as we did in 2023 which was 10 games under .500 at 76-86. Was that equal? No, same record, but much further removed from the Playoffs -

2023 10 under .500, lowest WC team - 6 games above .500 - Difference 16/2 = - 8 games

2024 10 under .500, lowest WC team- 17 games above .500 - Difference 27/2 = - 13.5 games

So, we added 4 difference makers - Oneil Cruz for a full year, ROY SP Paul Skenes, SP's Jared Jones and Bailey Falter for full years while losing only SP Johan Oviedo for a full year and Ke'Bryan Hayes for a half year and lost more ground in the race for the playoffs. 5 years of this is enough reason to find a new Manager and make the statement that this franchise and their fans want to make the playoffs rather than inventing more excuses for Derek Shelton!

Expand full comment

Well if you factor in how bad Bednar was, this team could have been much closer to .500. 8 losses by your closer will doom any team. Add in another 5 losses by Chapman. The back end of the pen crushed this team.

Expand full comment

Exactly.

To each their own but I think the club is in far better shape right now than they were at the same time last year. Ending up with the same amount of wins while losing your 3 WAR cornerstone third basemen and watching your entire bullpen implode is a *positive* sign.

Expand full comment

Yes, given that we added Skenes, Jones, and Cruz, finishing with the same record felt like a big step back.

Last year at this time it was easier to see where the improvement could come from within the organization This year, with the exception of Chandler, it seems like to improve we'll need to bring in wins from the outside. Is there any reason to feel optimistic about that?

Expand full comment

I see this completely opposite.

No team wins only with internal improvements.

This time last year you were HOPING those internal improvements actually came to fruition, and now we know they have.

By definition this makes it *easier* to see where the investments need to be made.

It's easier to improve the 2024 club than the 2023 club.

Expand full comment

We're not opposite as I agree that every team needs a mix of internal improvements and additions from outside the organization. I just meant that if everything else remained status quo, it was easy to expect improvement based on the players noted even if that wasn't enough to contend.

E.g., add ~6 wins from Cruz, Skenes, and Jones (though I wouldn't have expected nearly as much from Jones as we got), and we're at 82. Of course other parts of the team (Hayes, Suwinski, Bednar, Holderman) had unexpected drop-offs while the only unexpected bonus was from Bart. I.e., we didn't maintain status quo with the rest of the roster.

Expand full comment

Congrats to JT. Hopefully the first of two postseason awards for Pirates players.

Expand full comment

Rowdy for Comeback Player of the Year?

Expand full comment

Shelty for coach of the year of course

Expand full comment

That would make BC GM of the year and BN…..

Expand full comment

Sounds like a clean sweep if you ask me

Expand full comment

A very well deserved Gold Glove for Jared Triolo. For the past two years he has held the left side of the infield together after injuries to 3B Ke'Bryan Hayes, another Gold Glover. He was also very strong defensively at 2B, and SS while also seeing action at 1B and RF.

During this off-season I hope he figures out the swing that he wants to use - the exaggerated "high-Hands" pre-pitch approach cost him the regular job at 2B. He managed to get it together, dropped the hands, and with less head movement he found that he could actually see the ball better - his last 3 months were much better than the first three. Definitely at least the Pirates regular UT IF going into 2025, and maybe even more than that.

Expand full comment

Dump BDLC & IKF. Move JT into the Super U position and give Peggy the starting SS job and use the money saved to acquire a middle of the order 1B or RF. And hope like hell Hayes’ back is healthy.

Expand full comment

You're only saving money on SS by handing the position to a player who would not start for a single of the other 29 teams in the league.

That seems bad.

Expand full comment
Nov 4·edited Nov 4

I think as far as 2025 goes, the only attainable improvement at SS will come on the trade market. Teams that have mlb ready tradeable SS are slim, it should be an early target area. Cleveland, Mets, Diamondbacks, A's, and Dodgers are the teams that might part with their depth but not a given.

Kim is the only plausible free agent and his shoulder is a major question.

I don't think Peguero is the answer, I'd try to package him in a trade to a team needing a 2nd basemen or a right handed backup infielder (he had an .871 ops against lefties in Indy).

Expand full comment

Great post Scott - I had to look twice because it's something I would have posted. As a 22 year old in 2023, he posted 20 doubles and 11 HR in only 318 PA with a BB% of 10.1% and a K % of 18.2% at AA. The Pirates had him on a deliberate developmental path to possibly see the majors by 2025. That changed when Oneil Cruz was injured. When others failed, the Pirates turned to Peggy - he hit 7 HR in less than 200 AB with a .650 OPS at, the MLB level. Last year, high priced MLB Veteran SS IKF hit 1 HR with a .587 OPS in 218 AB for the Pirates. This is a no-brainer. Getting rid of IKF is even a bigger no-brainer.

Expand full comment