69 Comments

Missed the game, whos got a nice spicy recap?

Expand full comment

Pirates take early 4-1 lead due to some extremely beneficial BABIP luck. Pad lead to 7-1 after Reynolds doinks one off the RF Foul Pole. Priester looks great throwing upper 90’s fastballs for a few innings before giving up 4 runs in the blink of an eye. Bednar takes 7-5 lead into 9th and survives by an eyelash after striking out Abrams with one out and getting a fly out to end it with tying run on 3rd and go ahead run on 2nd.

Raise it!

Expand full comment

I nominate you for future spicy recaps. Excellent work.

Expand full comment

Agreed, perfect amount of spice!

Expand full comment

I can't watch the games but by commenters standards it was a typical drama filled Pirates win with Bednar providing late game excitement, lol.

Expand full comment

Now I am down to 8 !!!!!

Expand full comment

Just get to 73 so they can finish with 70 something wins and 80 something losses.

Then once there, if still possible, I’ll be rooting to get to 80 wins. Highly unlikely since they would have to go 12-4 the rest of the way.

Expand full comment

Of course I didn’t dare predict this before the game, but looking at Rutledge’s AAA stats I was pretty sure that even the Pirates were going to tee off against him.

Meanwhile, Bednar is really shaky at this stage of the season for the second year in a row.

Expand full comment

They didn’t tee off on him. Two pop ups that fell for hits inches from the foul line in the 1st inning, and a HR off the foul pole sealed his fate. Pirates had BABIP luck more than anything tonight.

Expand full comment

BTW, good factoid from Mackey that I had forgotten: Rutledge was taken one pick before Priester in the 2019 first round.

Expand full comment

Actually, it was one pick AFTER Priester.

Expand full comment

Anyhow, a win is a win and so raise it.

Expand full comment

Yikes...had em all the way lol

Expand full comment

Honestly I don't trust Bednar anymore. His pitch count is high again. I hope he proves me wrong.

Expand full comment

Unpopular opinion, but if I’m BC, he’s def being shopped this winter.

Expand full comment

What would you shop him for?

Expand full comment

Not sure what his trade value would be, but I’d prob look for a top 150 OF or SP prospect, a high upside arm as a potential replacement in a year or two, and a lottery ticket 🤷🏻‍♂️

Expand full comment

Somehow he did it, yay, but 30 pitches, 15 strikes, and just 3 whiffs

Expand full comment

Second half Bednar has been quite tedious at times.

Expand full comment

He doesn’t look great but he’d be out of the inning if the shortstop catches that pop up and the first baseman had thrown the ball to second base.

Expand full comment

Yeah, people always just blow those poor defensive plays off.

Expand full comment

This is a good point, but did he look good after that though? Missing location badly.

Expand full comment

Bednar really not missing bats

Expand full comment

At this point this is not surprising, Bednar has been mediocre for a while.

Expand full comment

Thank goodness all those times that Shelton misused him early in the season in no way affected him over the course of a season. I can't wait for Bednar to get to the off season. If this organization had any sense at all they would shut him down for the rest of the season!

Expand full comment

No matter what it's either Shelton's fault or Haines' fault.

Expand full comment

How was he misused?

Expand full comment

Too many attempts at multiple inning saves for a team that isn't competing for anything.

Expand full comment

Disagree somewhat on that. Per baseball reference, he’s come into games in the 8th inning seven times all season. Two of those were games they were losing rather handily and he hadn’t pitched in awhile so it was an effort to get him work.

In almost (not all but almost all) every other multi inning appearance he had multiple days off before and after the outing. I wouldn’t think that constitutes misuse.

Expand full comment

You're probably right, it just seems counter-intuitive to me watching any closer pitch more than one inning or not having a one inning pitch count. I do see a couple of other teams do multiples with closers and closers are volatile. I have a tendency to overreact with local guys playing at PNC.

Expand full comment

That’s a good point. Also several of his multi inning outings happened over a 2-3 week span right before the All-Star break so it seems like he’s been used more in multi inning stints than he really has.

It’s tough to juggle. You don’t really want to tank games by not using your best players, but you also don’t want to overuse them either. At least it’s scaled down in the second half; only 3 instances by my count. Of course, that may be necessitated by the fact that he’s been inefficient in this second half.

Expand full comment

Bednar looks awful

Expand full comment

Okay so tell me again, Williams and Rivas are both in the lineup solely because of their defense, right?

Expand full comment

Palacios covered a lot of ground.

Expand full comment

So this is Priester? Then who tf was that other guy a month ago?

Expand full comment

I liked this version way better tho- left a couple breaking balls up in the zone but the stuff looked better to me.

Expand full comment

Boy did you speak too soon. Although his ERA went down.

Expand full comment

He heard the footsteps of Jones, Skenes, and Bubba, and decided he better pick up the pace.

Expand full comment

Recognize him now?

Expand full comment

Oh, yeah. I guess it took him a while to realize he was back with the Pirates.

Expand full comment

Too many innings! His "good" run in AAA averaged five innings. That means 4+ good innings are possible in an MLB game. Do they really expect guys to do well for 6 innings in the majors when they don't pitch that deep in the minors? Ridiculous!

Expand full comment

Brown and Walk are so terrible.

Expand full comment

Walk’s okay. At least he talks about the game most of the time. Brown cannot stop rambling for even a few seconds and talks about nothing. His laughing out loud for 10-15 seconds after he says something only he thinks is even remotely funny makes my skin crawl. He’s one of the most annoying sport broadcasters I can ever remember.

Play-by-play broadcasters were meant for radio broadcasts to tell you what was happening on the field. Why they’re needed on TV broadcasts has always been beyond me. I can see what’s happening and don’t need nor want someone to tell me. They aren’t needed so wind up just filling the air with meaningless drivel and Brown has perfected that useless skill. The mute button helps some but when you unmute he’s still there endlessly pontificating.

Expand full comment

Half-right. Brown sucks, but Walk is good and has a nice dry sense of humor.

Expand full comment

Walk is fine. Brown can get on my nerves.

I can't remember if Walk does color on Peacock or Apple games, but happy he's in the booth on those games.

Expand full comment

What did they say/do now?

Expand full comment

Just their usual clown stuff involving some camera Bob decided to fixate on.

Expand full comment

Priester hit 96 and 97 if that gun is accurate.

Expand full comment

Statcast is accurate.

Expand full comment

I did not know that reading was direct from Statcast. Cool.

Expand full comment

It looks like he's in the 95 to 96 range consistently.

Expand full comment

This is encouraging to me

Expand full comment

Please let this be Hayes from now on!

Expand full comment