45 Comments
User's avatar
bmcferren's avatar

Can we please call up Jared Jones and let Tank be his catcher?

Expand full comment
Leefieux's avatar

Who plays RF then?

Expand full comment
bmcferren's avatar

Jack

I´m willing to give Bae one more shot in centerfield

Expand full comment
AdministrativeSky236's avatar

I think Bae is right where he should be, not on the roster

Expand full comment
bmcferren's avatar

how long until you think Jebb gets a shot?

Expand full comment
AdministrativeSky236's avatar

I would definitely be fine giving him a shot in center

Expand full comment
Leefieux's avatar

Then what do you do with Endy? Leave Tank in RF. I liked Bae, but was not impressed with his 2023 work on offense OR defense.

Expand full comment
bmcferren's avatar

was reading a few months ago that Jones and Davis have a good repoire

Expand full comment
AdministrativeSky236's avatar

I think we give tank 1-2 SP that he can become familiar with and catch a few times a week for next year

Expand full comment
John_Dreker's avatar

I was promised donuts and OJ if I showed up...

Expand full comment
Mel Schuster - emjayinTN's avatar

Well, I opted for the 20% off for a one year subscription. Very much enjoyed the work of Anthony and Bucs on P2 this year so subscribing to this start-up was a no-brainer. Hope everything is going well with you John.

Expand full comment
John_Dreker's avatar

I'm doing well, relegated to history writing at least until the end of the year. I'm good with that though, since I was doing it daily anyway. Just bored today while I wait for a site certificate update, so I popped in to see what was going on. I like how the comment section is set up here.

Expand full comment
Mel Schuster - emjayinTN's avatar

Just getting started, but I like the setup, and I'm a morning person, so the daily morning item, and the emphasis on the Bradenton A and FCL teams is excellent. Thrilled with where the Pirates are at heading into 2024, and still light candles and pray for a managerial change!

Expand full comment
John_Dreker's avatar

While the start of this year was definitely unexpected, the Pirates are right now where I predicted they would be back in March. I said below .500 before the All-Star break, play .500 ball after the break, 75 wins for the season. I could still see that happen

Expand full comment
Leefieux's avatar

OJ is still in prison right? I lost track.

Expand full comment
Anthony Murphy's avatar

I said donuts, nothing about OJ lol

Expand full comment
John_Dreker's avatar

I knew I should have got it in writing

Expand full comment
Leefieux's avatar

Bradenton had a couple of position players finish out that game.

Expand full comment
Anthony Murphy's avatar

Yep, things were so bad, that's a position player in the 'Top Pitcher' part of the Bradenton game lol

Expand full comment
Leefieux's avatar

Oh crap, I missed that, lol. I had checked last night and only remembered Juan Jerez.

Expand full comment
Anthony Murphy's avatar

Yep Tanner Tredaway ended up the only 'pitcher' worthwhile to put there lol. Juan Jerez, Tredaway and Deivis Nadal all pitched lol

Expand full comment
Anthony Murphy's avatar

That game was frustrating as it is. A couple of REALLY BAD missed calls didn't help. Nolasco doubled down the line, clear as day foul, but ump called it foul. Castillo caught one leaning into dugout, but they didn't call it out. Automatic Strike Zone screwed De Los Santos over, called a clear ball a strike 3. Rough night all around.

Expand full comment
Leefieux's avatar

I’ve read where that auto strike zone is having issues with large breaking balls.

Expand full comment
NolaJeffy(BnP)'s avatar

I think it was JJ I saw mention it, but I think they've moved to a single plane in the middle of the zone. a plane at the front and back was giving big problems with breakers. Cause high ones would clip top of back plane, and low ones the bottom of front plane.

Expand full comment
Anthony Murphy's avatar

It was a breaking ball high. Very clearly not a strike. Called strike three

Expand full comment
Leefieux's avatar

‘ Top Pitcher - Yunior This: 1.1 IP, H’

We have a P named ‘This’. Is This any good? Or is This just filler? Is This age appropriate? Has This gotten old?

Expand full comment
Anthony Murphy's avatar

Fixed. You have now idea how long I fought with autocorrect on his FIRST name just to go right past fixing his last name lol

Expand full comment
Leefieux's avatar

Btw, Autocorrect is as annoying as heck, but I didn’t make it a week with it off, lol.

Expand full comment
Anthony Murphy's avatar

I wouldn't last a day without it lol

Expand full comment
Leefieux's avatar

I was gonna just Tweet that to you, but the Joke Factor was too high to ignore. 😜😜

Expand full comment
Jim Deweese's avatar

Grateful for this site :) Please help fill in my withdrawal from the decline @ PP2

Expand full comment
AdministrativeSky236's avatar

Excited for the gameday threads! Pretty content with the return on the santana trade, would probably take something similar for hill assuming he goes. Though, I have no good idea on who is going to pick up those innings once he does

Expand full comment
Anthony Murphy's avatar

My only concern is who gets those innings if Hill is gone. Luis Ortiz? Roansy Contreras? Neither seem ideal really.

Expand full comment
WTM's avatar

Erik Bedard would like to make a comeback.

Expand full comment
Anthony Murphy's avatar

Funny story about Erik Bedard, I was a really big fan of his, so I was excited to see him pitch for the Pirates the first time. Left work early, got into a car accident on way home, first thing I asked doctor 'Do you think I'll be home in time to watch the Pirates game' lol. I wasn't.

Expand full comment
WTM's avatar

The doc was just shielding you from disappointment.

Expand full comment
Anthony Murphy's avatar

Doctors know best, right? Lol

Expand full comment
NolaJeffy(BnP)'s avatar

Well for one thing, I don't remember this many names thrown around last year. It was more everyone calling on Reynolds, as expected, and then us mentioning who we thought maybe would get calls. As of now, I've seen: Hill, Holderman, Keller, and Bednar

I won't be surprised if they end up trading just a couple more warm bodies.

Expand full comment
CL10's avatar

Bednar to the Dbacks for Druw and a pitching prospect. Won't happen but a man can dream

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jul 28, 2023
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
CL10's avatar

Ya, can't argue that. Not much confidence in our hitting development

Expand full comment
Zack's avatar

Great to see Solometo settle down and complete five innings. Is there a place to track down advanced metrics and pitch spin/movement for his Altoona starts?

Expand full comment
AdministrativeSky236's avatar

I looked on the savant page but it didnt seem like they had data for this start so i dunno

Expand full comment
Zack's avatar

I did the same this morning. I couldn’t find any game data just the traditional stat lines.

Expand full comment
Anthony's avatar

I think it’s only available for the FSL and all of AAA.

Expand full comment
Anthony Murphy's avatar

Yep for the Pirates system, it's only Bradenton and Indianapolis we can get data for. They have tracking in Altoona and probably Greensboro, just not available to the public

Expand full comment