112 Comments

Why not try and swing a trade for Dylan Carlson, honestly? Cards need pitching. I don't know what's wrong with the guy but he looked like a really good young switch hitting CF in '21 and '22 and the Cards haven't exactly been the most functional show on earth since then. A bit of a history taking walks and with some baserunning value, too. He's listed as a guy who played through injury in '23. Shut him down for a month and aim at calling him up mid-August. Might take a minor overpay in division but wouldn't cost much.

Expand full comment

Welp

https://x.com/_NoahHiles/status/1811101327432311268

Not so near a deal on Ward.

Expand full comment

So two reporters from the same paper with different reports on the same story. 🙈

Expand full comment

I'd take Hiles version over Zeise, he has more to prove being on the beat, while Zeise is more opinion based.

Expand full comment

I appreciate that, I don’t live in the area so this helps.

Expand full comment

Sort of like the offseason when the Pirates "showed interest" in every name on the board and ended up overpaying for waiver-wire junk.

Expand full comment

I think that's probably a feature of Cherington agonizing over decisions as was mentioned in an article 2-3 weeks back

Expand full comment

Seeing the comments below. Here are my questions:

Is Ward an upgrade?

Is he a difference maker on his own?

Is he a difference maker in his potential to lengthen the lineup and help someone else see better pitches?

Expand full comment

Upgrade, for sure, difference maker, unlikely. But if were are giving up Ashcroft and Jebb like someone suggested I will do it in a heartbeat. Ward and Palacios ( no a true platoon since I will give Ward the vast majority of the at bats) will make a solid RF.

Expand full comment

Virtually anybody is an upgrade. Literally.

Expand full comment

No doubt. Depending on what they have to give up, the move makes sense.

Expand full comment

Man, I don't know if Ward would improve the team or not. I get the appeal from the front office as Ward has high bb% and that's their MO.

Expand full comment

Plaz just hit his 11th homerun.

Expand full comment

Paul Zeise tweets Bucs are in on Taylor Ward. Fillipponi tweets Zeise is saying the Bucs are close to acquiring Ward.

Expand full comment

Weird to think about this. Ben has never traded for a real major leaguer before. Just guys who were dfa’d or whose teams wanted to dump a little salary, like Choi.

Expand full comment

Edward Olivares resents that statement.

Expand full comment

Pablo Sandoval night terrors are still keeping him awake.

Expand full comment

Ward’s 957 ops versus lefties looks nice

Expand full comment

Something like Ashcraft and Brannigan maybe? Cheap. Slightly above league average bat. Bad defense. Crushes lefties and 92 wRC+ against RHP. Could be underperforming a bit because the Angels are even more depressing than the Pirates as an org. Sort of sounds like I'm describing Connor Joe though as I type this. We'd still need a platoon bat for Joe unless he's now 100% platoon at 1B and bench bat?

Expand full comment

On paper he is an upgrade over any outfield spot (pretty easy to accomplish) other than Reynolds but he is not a huge difference maker IMO. I wish he could play center because MAT is the easy cut here but who the heck plays center against lefties? I am trying not to be a prospect hugger but would rather not give up Ashcraft in this trade as he is 'near' term starting depth (and hopefully more than just 'depth'). I like the Joe/Tellez combo for now at 1B with the lame rationale that Joe playing less outfield and only against lefties will help get him back on track.

Expand full comment

This is the perfect description of him, like everything else depends on what’s traded. But even though he’s an upgrade, he is not a difference maker.

Expand full comment

Ward has been in almost as big a slump as Joe in his last 30 games, OPS is just over .600 in that time frame.

Expand full comment

So can the Pirates get him for less?

Expand full comment

I would hope, but who knows.

Expand full comment

A few days with Haines should change that.

Expand full comment

Ugh, well. If it happens probably just Cherington trying to say "see, I did something!" and I'll wish Ward the best here particularly given he'd be here for a few years.

Expand full comment

I'd much rather them try and get a Barrosa from Arizona, elite defensive CFer with good on base skills. Should be a lot cheaper both in prospects and payroll.

Expand full comment

I could see them being reluctant to go for a guy who hasn't put it together at MLB yet for any stretch given all the AAA to MLB failure this season wrt Barrosa. Not saying they're right to but could be a reason he might not get targeted. Not for failure at MLB ofc since he's only had 10 PAs in the bigs. Just lack of "proven" bat.

Expand full comment

I totally get that, it's a risk but I'd love to see an Ashcraft and Sullivan for Barrosa and pick 35 in this draft lol. With both teams getting prospects in positions of need.

Expand full comment

If true, big if, I’d imagine there would be a substantial piece going back considering the years of control. Those two could be involved. Unless we are following someone’s suggestion yesterday of taking Anthony Rendon. Lolololol.

Expand full comment

I think it's fun to model whackadoo trades so here's a Rendon one:

Ward

Rendon + $45M

Reid Detmers (on rehab right now but a solid LHSP we could add to Skenes, Keller Jones

Nelson Rada (intriguing CF #1 LA prospect)

for

Ashcraft

Jebb

Hayes

Expand full comment

Lololol. Love it. That’d be a great occasional segment for some publication to run. Just have a writer model a few ridiculous trades and try to rationalize them.

Expand full comment

I can't say I get that particular player, honestly. I guess two Connor Joes (Ward is a bit better than Joe but similar skillset) are better than one?

Expand full comment

Yeah it seems a bit redundant, but, and this is big words coming from me: there isn’t much out there so if they do manage to get Ward we should probably cut them a break. Where would they play these guys though? Neither player (him or Joe) grades out well in range. Ward seems to have a cannon though.

Expand full comment

I would guess Joe would remain a platoon partner for Tellez.

Ward would either platoon with JP or be the primary RF.

Suwinski would be the primary CF'er with Taylor as his caddy.

Seems like an awful lot of OF'ers, but I struggle to see a scenario where Taylor is not on the roster, due to him being the only real CF'er.

Expand full comment

And the fact that MAT is pretty much the only one with any kind of range.

Expand full comment

At the very least, Ward seems like he has some upside after the 137 wRC+ 2022 he had _if_ he fits well with this roster and coaching staff.

Here's an Angels fan's take on a Ward deal from the Pirates https://crashingthepearlygates.com/2024/07/01/what-a-realistic-taylor-ward-trade-might-net/ but BTV has since tweaked their values a bit and Ashcraft is up to a 10.7 now for whatever that's worth. Ashcraft and Jebb alone are pretty close by their estimate.

Expand full comment

I see major regression for the Brewers in the 2nd half. Rotation outside of Peralta is dogshit, multiple hitters overperforming and the pen will be taxed by August. Cards are due for regression as well.

Buccos are going to make a run out of this!

Expand full comment

The opportunity certainly is there. The rest of the NLC just isn’t that impressive. And no other team has a force as powerful as the Pgh rotation.

Expand full comment

Oneil Cruz is going to have a monster second half

He he has shaken off the cobwebs from last years tim eoff and if about to go big time

Expand full comment

From your mouth to God's ears I pray you're right!

Expand full comment

Then all we'd have to do is replace Hayes with a 3B who can hit and field, get a RF platoon bat for Joe a la Jesse Winker a MLB CF and probably one good bullpen arm and we'd have a contender! That's not asking much. Just 2.5 starters and a reliever.

Expand full comment

I think there is some upside with the offense. But, like you said, why wait so long to cut bait with dudes like Olivares?

It was encouraging seeing Bart start game one of a three game series...maybe, just maybe, Bart will start getting the lions share.

Is the Palacios effect real?

Expand full comment

I don’t see Palacios as any kind of medium term answer, but sometimes a guy just gets hot, so go with it. That’s why it’s so dumb to drag along with a -0.8 WAR guy like Olivares. Keep trying guys until somebody gets hot. The costs of making moves with guys like that are nonexistent. The risk lies in keeping them too long.

Expand full comment

Fwiw, Dejan has an article today insisting that Nuttin has authorized lots more spending but Cherington won’t do it.

Whatever. Bottom line is, an opportunity exists now and they don’t want it.

The Mets had bullpen problems against the Bucs and immediately dealt for Phil Maton, because, y’know, nobody makes trades now. Maton isn’t exactly exciting, but when you’re playing guys as awful as the Pirates are, “exciting” isn’t required for an upgrade.

Expand full comment

Noteworthy because recent events do suggest a level of dysfunction in this front office spilling into the public eye, the dysfunction being discernible for awhile now to anyone watching closely.

Expand full comment

Geez oh man if only Bob were in a position to do something about it!

Expand full comment

"Ben, please spend some of my $"

"No Bob, I'm not spending your $"

In the workplace, they call this insubordination.

Expand full comment

Hard to believe that management would go to an employee and say “hey I have extra funds for your budget” and the employee would say: “nah I’m cool.”

Expand full comment

More like the owner going to the VP and saying, "Please invest more into this company so the stock rises."

and the VP says no.

That's very hard to believe.

Expand full comment

Yeah, I don’t know what to believe. In the end it doesn’t matter.

Expand full comment

Honestly did not have this on my Pirate bingo card.

Coonelly-Huntington circled the wagons like no other.

Expand full comment

It's like reading the tabloids waiting in line at the grocery store

Expand full comment

It's exhausting. They could cut the crap and infighting theatrics and just try to get better or get honest with the fans and say aloud that they don't think this is the year or whatever but they're bullshit artists first and foremost, Nutting and Cherington both, so they won't.

Expand full comment

Sure seems like a divide and conquer strategy to divert the fan base to pick sides so they don't have to actually address the situation.

Expand full comment

Again fwiw, there DOES seem to be some tension. Nuttin’s and Cherington’s comments about trades were directly contradictory.

Due to Skenes, the Pirates are getting media attention for the first time in Ben’s reign of error. Their needs and the opportunity they have are so painfully clear that it HAS to have occurred to some of the dim bulbs on Federal St that there’ll be widespread bafflement if they continue to sit on their hands and fall out of the race. So I can imagine some of those dim bulbs want to get their supposed story out.

Expand full comment

Beautifully said! "Ben's reign of error"

Expand full comment

On the contrary, I think this front office is getting a pass of epic proportions because of Skenes.

Expand full comment

Maybe I'm wrong, but hasn't Dejan been making stuff up about the Pirates for decades? Didn't he claim NH tried to get him fired?

Expand full comment

People are likewise questioning Perrotto’s more credible (IMO) reporting. Who knows what to believe.

Expand full comment

Or maybe the anonymous source is a bullshitter and a disgruntled employee? Either way, it's silly drama and I have zero interest in any of it.

Expand full comment

I think it’d be easier to write it off that way if it wasn’t for the contradictory nature of the reporting. I have no interest in the palace intrigue as such, but I am deeply concerned with what I feel is dysfunction in the organization.

Expand full comment

I love palace intrigue. As long as it’s someone else’s palace.

Expand full comment

Too bad it isn’t the Brewers or Reds.

Expand full comment

It also claims that the O's offered Jackson Holliday for Jared Jones! And Cherington said no. If that's true he should get fired twice and banned from baseball.

Expand full comment

If true, I’d bet there were other players in the offer.

Expand full comment

For sure. Cruz and Jones don't even get you Holliday imo.

Expand full comment

If you actually believe that you also believe in the Easter Bunny.

Expand full comment

I don't believe it but if we ever get corroborating sources, Cherington should be immediately shitcanned.

Expand full comment

I heard Rowdy is going to be an AS replacement...just waiting for the corroborating sources.

Expand full comment

Do you always have to be a c word or?

Expand full comment

that'll get you tossed on this board and every Major League stadium, lol

Expand full comment

corroborating?

Expand full comment

Pen should be ok when Borucki and Bednar come back.

Expand full comment

I hope they saved some runs for tonight and tomorrow

Expand full comment

Tuesday, July 9

44 down. 37 to go.

*

Pirates win 12-2 at Milwaukee behind a strong bulk performance by Quinn Priester and another outing by the Ogres at the Bat Rack, who clubbed 5 bombs. The Pirates are in third place, 8.5 games out of first and 1.5 games out of last. Time to compress these standings a bit and sweep the Brewers. It’s a big series, citizen, so let’s go on and get it.

*

CARROTS ON THE HOUSE!!!! (*not enough carrots to go around edition)

@> A carrot for Josh Palacios, welcome back, cousin!

@> A carrot for B.Rey because damn is that a fine baseball player.

@> A carrot for Rowdy because damn is this guy catching fire. Nice to see him do it to the Brewers in their ear-hole.

@> A carrot for Mike Wazowski for his 2 for 5 night with a bomb and, importantly, no strikeouts.

@> A carrot for Joey Bart for his granny.

@> A carrot for QP (stands for Quality Pitching) for joining the parade of fine arms finally jelling at the big league level. And welcome, welcome, welcome to the Carrot Leader Board, Mighty Quinn!

*

Truly a team effort with not enough credit to go around. Needs to continue today and on through the week. It is exciting to think of what this rotation will become, but if the Ogres report to work at the Bat Rack more often, we’re in the bonus round. I’ll believe the consistency when I see it, ,but - hey - 11 hits and five of them goners? Let’s have that.

___________________________

“I taught I taw a puddy tat! I did! I did tee a puddy tat!!!”

-Wabbit

Expand full comment

I've never not thought Quinn can be successful if his FB velo is 95 or higher and was only concerned when he seemed to be topping out at 93. So, seeing those velo numbers makes me cautiously optimistic.

Expand full comment

Really good to see QP and Ortiz pitching well and holding their velocity. The organization is getting pretty stacked with quality right hand starting pitching. At the majors Skenes, Jones and Keller with QP and Ortiz knocking on the door. Upper minors with Ashcraft, Chandler and Harrington coming up the walk way and aren't far from the door.

Seems like a couple guys like Sullivan and Chen could be good trade pieces for a blocked prospect in other organizations. The other team isn't getting the pirates best but the pirates aren't getting their best either but could be an upgrade for both.

Expand full comment

My concern with the Pirates bats waking up is it will cause them to keep Haines next year.

We all know the 85 game sample size of meh offense is much more indicative than the 5 game sample of the 70’s Lumber Company. But I’m definitely here to enjoy this ride while it lasts.

Expand full comment

Ugh!

Yeah it's a true catch 22. I want the Pirates to keep hitting well and finally have the competitive offense to compliment their pitching. But I also want to be rid of the burden of Haines who IMO has lead to regression of all their ML bats.

Expand full comment

I guess the other way to look at it.. if 'this ride' does last for the rest of the year (absolutely not a prediction), then should they keep him? The organizational wide lack of hitters might not be the major league coaches fault. I certainly hope we have this dilemma (ie. the 'ride' continued).

Expand full comment

Hoping the Barco move is load management

Expand full comment
author

I imagine it is. His senior season in 2022, he threw 50.1 innings before going down with TJS. His season high is 83.0 IP in 2021 junior season. He's already at 62.0 IP this year.

Which, on that note, there's A LOT of pitchers ready to eclipse previous highs in short order. Carlson Reed is 1 inning from blowing past his 2022 total of 63.1 IP between college and summer ball.

Expand full comment

I was just going to post this.

Great minds and all. 😎

Expand full comment