57 Comments

McKinney goes BOOM!?!?!?! How the hell did that happen?

Expand full comment

Palacios better get back soon or McKinney is going to take his roster spot.

Expand full comment

McKinney reminds me of Ben Gamel.

Expand full comment

If he is your 4th or 5th OF, that is not a bad thing.

Expand full comment

Hmmm. Garret Forrester is catching at PC.

Expand full comment

I remember reading somewhere that pre-draft some teams had tried him out as a catcher.

Expand full comment

I think I posting on P2 during the draft that I didn't like the pick unless they were going to give him a try at catcher. It makes me like the pick better.

Expand full comment

It’s really the most sensible move. He’s not going to stick defensively at third and he doesn’t have the power for first.

Expand full comment

He has catching experience? I know that we drafted him as an infielder

Expand full comment

Better than 1b where he is destined. Back up catcher, 1b will of course increase his chances.

Expand full comment

They left a catcher’s mitt on the bench as bait and Garret happened to pick it up. He was trapped……

Expand full comment

Nikki G. saw 3 FB at 95, down 0-2 in the count, then line drive on a slider. Hmmm.

Expand full comment

But now he just made a play that Wehner and Brown called one of the best you'll ever see.

Expand full comment

Smh.....I did not know there was radio today. Thx!

Expand full comment

I couldn't get mine to work.

Expand full comment

He is looking much better at the plate. His strike out rate is less than the Pirates team in spring training so far.

Pirates team 18%

Peguero 8%

Nick G. 15%

Bae 24%

Triolo 30%

Expand full comment

And then a TOOTBLAN as the trail runner at 1B.......wth is he thinking?

Expand full comment

Am I missing some more of that Shelton led small ball?

Expand full comment

No, Nick got picked off 1B by the catcher! That's an example of falling asleep and also I'll call out first base coach too. Since it wasn't televised, not sure who that was today.

Expand full comment

Thanks, unable to watch or listen to the game. While I totally agree about the responsibility being in this particular instance on Nick and the 1st base coach but this happens so often with multiple players on this team during the Shelton era from seasoned veterans to the youngest players and there is a disconnect between the coaching and having these guys totally prepared for game situations. These types of situations happen too often with this team.

Expand full comment

He’s thinking, What would a Pirate do?

Expand full comment

WWWCD

What Would Will Craig Do?

Expand full comment

That was one of the worst plays in the history of baseball. That being said, I put a blame also on the Pirates teammates that should have been shouting at him to touch first base.

Expand full comment

Bases loaded, no outs. Called third and a snap pickoff. Spring training on how to kill an inning.

Expand full comment

Looks like Falters and Anderson should be all set to handle the split squad B games. How many of those do we have?

Expand full comment

Assuming they're not ready to promote Jones, then a viable rotation in April should be

Keller

Perez/Anderson piggy-back

Priester/Gonzales piggy-back

Contreras/Falter piggy-back

Lauer/Ortiz piggy-back

All of the piggy-back guys need to prove that they can pitch more than 3-4 innings; use April to see who earns that opportunity. If Jones makes the roster, then I'd use Lauer out of the pen and have Ortiz in AAA as starting pitching depth (subject to change based on how Ortiz looks in his next couple of outings).

Expand full comment

Has priester earned a spot in mlb vs AAA?

Expand full comment

We don't have 13 guys in camp who have earned a spot, but I wouldn't mind if Priester starts off in AAA. It's just that he's on the 40-man and once you start adding guys like Lauer (who I'm intrigued about), Anderson, Peralta, etc., you're having to DFA guys.

Expand full comment

I loved the piggy-backs after the All-Star game last season (out of necessity), but we don't have the 2 extra roster spots like they did in September. Makes it tough to do.

Expand full comment

I would like to see us have a long reliever ready for every game. Let the starter keep pitching, if he is doing well. Take him out early if he is struggling. With our inconsistency from our staff, I wouldn't like to see a schedule edged in stone.

Expand full comment

They would need the piggy-back guys to be able to pitch an inning on their bullpen days between starts, or it could overstretch their pen. A more realistic arrangement would be 2-3 traditional starters and 2-3 piggy-back games instead of four.

Expand full comment

Just do it Tampa style and shuttle players back and forth from AAA to the bigs.

Expand full comment

Watching JP Massey at Pirate City. He’s walked 3 of the first 4 hitters.

Expand full comment

Not exactly the start you want to see after the finish he had

Expand full comment

Drake Fellows looks good, though. Seen him three times already.

Expand full comment

Isn't Fellows older than Rich Hill?

Expand full comment

He’s older than all the hills.

Expand full comment

Since we acquired him or this year?

Expand full comment

This year.

Expand full comment

Not that I want it to happen but I could see McKinney being the 4th outfielder. He has played every outfield spot and first. He has also been hitting well 350 avg. Could see him making it over palacios, bae and CSN.

Expand full comment

But, we traded to get Olivares and Celestino has the positive CF innings at the MLB level, a strong ST, and is out of options. And we also have Connor Joe who will see time in the OF. In most ST he would look good for the Pirates, but not this year! Can't fit him into the 26.

Expand full comment

I think Olivares is a lock but there’s one spot open among Bae, Palacios, CSN, McKinney and if you want to throw in Celestino. I don’t think Celestino makes it but not sure which of the others listed will. I think it’s a toss up.

Expand full comment

Do the Pirates have the option of sending Celestino down?

Expand full comment

He's on a minor league deal, and I think that will be the major factor in him not making the Opening Day roster. They'll surely place Moreta on the 60-day IL to open a spot, but that may be Jones' spot.

Expand full comment

He’s not on the 40 man. I would assume but could be wrong.

Expand full comment

He has had somewhat of rough-go of it in the majors, but seems to have potential. Personally I would like to see him get a month of success under his belt in the minors first.

Expand full comment

He's certainly seeing a lot of action in ST....

Expand full comment

He's walked 7 times in 27 ABs........must be getting DS attention! And there's also the cash considerations that BC spent to get him.......gotta give him the Van Meter treatment.

Expand full comment

And another walk. Give that man a contract. BC loves OBP.

Expand full comment

Yeah he’s a lock now haha

Expand full comment

Braves sending their B team today, as expected. Good to see Gonzales back in our lineup, though clearly they're wanting to see if he can handle a utility role by playing him at SS with Triolo at 2B.

Expand full comment

With Liover Peguero (2B/SS) and Jared Triolo 3B/2B/SS) onboard, and the type of Spring that Termarr Johnson is having, I see the Pirates as trying to showcase NG for a possible trade.

Expand full comment

Stumpf has an interesting article up about Lauer, including Lauer's use of a mental skills coach. I'm looking forward to seeing Lauer on the mound.

Stumpf did make one big mis-statement that I've seen others make. Historically, there are more off days in April than other months. This year, though, we only have three off-days from the Opener on March 28 through the end of April. In May, though, we have five off days. In June we have four. In fact, March/April has fewer off days than any month until September when we only have two off days.

Expand full comment

What is the average number of postponements per month? He says off days and not scheduled games. Weather would be a factor. There seem to be many more in April compared to other months. Is data on that available anywhere? Looking at the Pirate's schedule, I would expect at least 1 to 2 games postponed in April.

Expand full comment

Stumpf is also on FGs effectively wild podcast this week, with a Bucs preview. EW runs twice a week, and pairs two teams together on previews as they get towards the season starting. It’s a good listen.

Expand full comment

To state the obvious, with our rotation so unsettled and Bednar possibly facing a delayed start to the season, our April schedule is doing us no favors (but at least we'll have a lot of baseball to watch :)).

Expand full comment

Saw that about April, and that's going to eliminate the likelihood of carrying 14 position players. It's probably going to be 13/13 split.

Expand full comment